So as you may know we are TWO just TWO WEEKS away from one of the most important finales in PLL history, this Summer Finale we will find out something we had been waiting for YEARS, the identity of "A" aka the lost older brother of Alison and Jason Dilaurentis : Charles Dilaurentis. Charles/A has been the girl's tormentor since way back then when Mona was revealed as the first "A" and then stole the game from her and now we know some of his history and horrible childhood: when he was six years old he tried to drown a little baby Alison, for that reason he was sent to Radley where he lived almost all his childhood and adolesence, he celebrated his birthday with his siblings once and said it was the best one he ever had, he faked his death at the age of 16 with the help of this mother, Jessica Dilaurentis and the night Alison dissapeared he went back to Radley and it seems like he helped Bethany Young escape that night, when she supposedly died. He wanted to trust Jason.
and recently we found out he is clearly NOT working alone, cause last episode we saw Red Coat who is back to help Charles and it seems they have been working together for a long time now cause she refer to herself (I'm assuming is a woman) as Charles "friend and ally" hhhmmmm...
SO obviously this information is important, but what we want to know is something even more important, who is this people behind the masks and the coats and the hoodie? why are they doing this? is this people we trust? I bet you all have your theories ready and are waiting for August 11 to see if you're right! well so do I, so let me share with you my main suspects for Charles and his allies Red Coat and Black Veil.
CHARLES DILAURENTIS / "A"
My main suspect is : Wren Kingston.
So I know this theory is probably the most sounded and popular right now but cmon people it's for a reason, and that's because all the clues point out to him since season 3 and even back then since season 1. And how can our favorite british doctor with those cute dimples and smile be this psychopath who was been tormenting the girls for years? Well that's exactly why. He is just one of those characters that nobody will suspect at the begining he is charmful and helpful i can't remember of someone in the show that didn't like Dr. Wren Kingston, well obviously there were exceptions like Veronica Hastings who hated him because well he broke her daughter's heart because he kissed with her other daugther so that's a strong reason i guess. And then there were only 2 people who never really trusted cute smile Wren and that's: Mona and Eddie Lamb. If you remember back in season 3 Spencer was asking Eddie Lamb about Mona being in Radley and while she was asking she said that Dr. Kingston said Mona was obssessed with the A game and Eddie's response was really weird, and that made me remember something that happened this season espisode 6X07 when Aria tells Mona that someone she talked to in Radley stole the game from her, Mona talked with various characters in Radley but guess who was there with her all the time and had access to his files and visitor's access? yeah. (credits to wren.is.charles on instagram you should totally check them out!)
And Mona always said she don't really remember who was she talking in Radley because she was in so many drugs she was confused all the time, we do saw Red Coat talking to her on the season 2 finale but i wonder if Mona remember that conversation she had with Wren where he showed her a drawing (very familar btw) and talked about him being keeping secrets from her and loyalties which is weird cause what does Wren has do with Mona??? AND this episode is for me the key for Wren shadiness, go back and watch episose 4x10 "The Mirror has Three Faces." Wren also gets asked by Hanna why did he let Cece in to see Mona and ask if she has contacted him which he quickly denies, but we'll talked about that later, at the last scence we see Wren coloring the woman in the drawing coat's red. coincidence? i think not.
Even Julian Morris (the actor who portrays Wren) has been posting little clues on his snapchat.
Wren has been around since the pilot, and he just came in and had the girls completely fooled, they have talked, kissed him, and not one time they ever suspected him. They have suspected Ezra, Toby, Caleb, Paige, ect every wrong person, but Dr.Kingston has never been in the A list.
THERE PLENTY OF OTHER CLUES IF YOU WANT TO SEE EVEN MORE CLUES AND PROOF THAT CHARLES IS WREN WATCH THIS VIDEO -
Now let's move on to RED COAT.
Main Suspect: Cece Drake.
She has been around since forever, even though she was introduced till season 3 we learn she has been there since WAY before, she was in Cape May, and also she was there on the night Alison dissapeared and she was one of the girls wearing the famous yellow top. So the question is why could her motivation be and how is she connected to Charles (Wren) how does she fits into all of this? for me this is very difficult to explain and i have a lot of whole in my theories but what if, just what IF Cece is actually Bethany Young? cmon we have all thought she is still alive and it would make sense. Think Bethany was in Radley just like Charles they could have meet there and became good friends. Charles helped her escape that night and she was somehow hit in the head in the process, Melissa buried her and Charles pulls her out, who hit her? i have no idea, could had been Spencer or one of the other girls and that will explain their motivation, but this theory brings another question if Alison was pulled out, and Bethany was pulled out too, who's body is in the grave? Now keep up with me okay cause this is a strech. We had been getting clues since the begining about twins, girl twins. What if the twins are Cece and Bethany maybe they grew up in bad terms and hated each other and while they were little one of them tried to hurt the other maybe Bethany tried to hurt Cece and when their parents find out, Bethany pretended to be Cece and Cece was the one who was sent to Radley instead of Bethany because their parents confused them ( THIS is what happens in the books in case you don't know) Charles meets her and she tells him her story they planned the whole thing together and maybe they kill Bethany the real one and somehow in the process Cece gets hit in the head by whoever, then Melissa buries the real Bethany and Cece is also buried and Charles pulls her out.( I KNOW IS TOO MUCH) Maybe Bethany pretending to be Cece ( Alison's friend we saw on the flashbacks) was dressed in the yellow top and Charles was going to hit HER to help his friend Cece (the real Cece) cuase that was the plan and end up hitting Alison by accident cause they looked so much alike, and that's why Mrs. D buries Alison and tell him and Cece "what have you done" maybe mrs.D already knew about the Cece-Bethany thing, so then Charles (wren) and Cece has been working together ever since.
REMEMBER that twin story Alison tells in season 2, episose 2x13 " The First Secret" the girls look a lot like, yeah you guessed it: Cece Drake.
Also like i said before after Hanna asks Wren is Cece have contacter him, he denies it so damn quickly and when Hanna leaves Wren makes a phone call and tells someone that "they got a problem" i wonder what that is.
THERE ARE PLENTY OF OTHER CLUES IF YOU WANT TO SEE MORE ABOUT WHY CECE IS RED COAT WATCH THIS VIDEO -
and finally BLACK VEIL
main suspect : Melissa Hastings.
Some people think that Red Coat and Black Veil are the same person, but i don't think that's the case. They had said that Black Veil is endgame, and we had seen her just in funerals: at Wilden's and at Bethany's. I think that Black Veil is good, and the fact that she is going to this people's funerals shows that she is sorry for what happened to them. Wilden was killed by Cece, he was Melissa's friend. I think Melissa is being black mailed by Wren (Charles) , I think she didn't know at the begining his game was going to be this crazy, she killed bethany, she finished the job for them and if she talks she is going down with them, on the other part, she is also there because she is trying to protect Spencer which she had said a million times, she said she buried Bethany because she thought Spencer had hit her, maybe she did it not knowing she was getting into a very dangerous game and interfiering with Wren and Cece's plan, then she meets Wren and somehow she figure out his intentions and he black mails telling her that if she talks he would tell she killed Bethany, so that's why we see her going to Bethany's funeral and writing a card that said " my deepest condelences" because she feels bad and guilty but can't do anything about. Also remember she is back with Wren in London conveniently.
THERE'S PLENTY OF CLUES BUT IF YOU WANT TO SEE MORE ABOUT BLACK WIDOW BEING MELLISSA WATCH THIS VIDEO -
THIS ARE JUST THEORIES MERE EXPECULATIONS, I COULD BE TOTALLY WRONG, i'm just putting my thoughts out there, and after the finale you could me come here and is if i was right! ARE YOU READY FOR THIS? :
Who killed Toby’s mother? Who hit Alison in the head with the rock the night she went missing? Who is Red Coat? Who killed Bethany? Who is the Black Widow? Why has ‘A’ been targeting the PLLs all this time? After years of torture, Alison, Aria, Emily, Hanna and Spencer finally come face-to-face with their tormentor and learn the story of how and why Charles became ‘A.’
